Minutemen Are People, Too
win a round against the ACLU.
The Wall Street Journal
It is just so refreshing to see a story in a mainstream publication get
After all the bigoted trash the news media propogated about the Minuteman
the Wall Street Journal publishes an accurate account,
and holds the media's feet to the fire.
[Presented here for fair-use, non-profit, educational purposes only,
as part of an examination of blatant high-profile news-media bias.]
BY LEO W. BANKS
TUCSON, Ariz.--Anybody who appreciates a good yuck was sad to see the
Minutemen pack up their pickups and go home. After all, it wasn't every
day that we got to enjoy the spectacle of sunscreen-lathered ACLU observers
chasing volunteer border-watchers through the desert. But in the media
bonfire accompanying Arizona's Redneck Revolt, we saw the cultural divide
separating media elites from ordinary people--those with BlackBerries
and $150 hairdos versus folks with tobacco bulges in their cheeks.
In the view of most of the reporters who parachuted into Arizona for this
story and, disturbingly, local ones as well, you'd get the distinct impression
that the Minutemen are the problem along the border. That's right. America
needn't worry about the thousands who bust into the country every night.
No, the real danger are those yahoos who think calling the cops when they
see somebody breaking the law is a good idea.
Never mind that it worked, more or less. In April, the number of illegals
coming across along the Naco corridor, where the Minutemen were stationed,
fell, even if the balloon effect pushed them to other places along Arizona's
350-mile-long border with Mexico. But that's not the story most editors
and producers wanted. They wanted to stand up the angle that went something
like--no, exactly like--this: Gun-toting vigilantes run amok in the desert,
hunting harmless illegals who are only looking for work.
So, you show up in gritty Tombstone, grab somebody wearing a straw hat
and a sidearm and work him for the quotes you want. Then you shoot film
of the guy wearing his gun, because that's what the producer said in the
story meeting, and if you're lucky you get a big grin on the subject's
face showing gaps where teeth should be.
I've been a reporter in Arizona for 30 years. As the border story has
heated up, I get calls from out-of-town reporters wanting me to hook them
up with angry border residents. If I mentioned in a story that a particular
rancher carries a gun, that's the rancher the reporters want to see. They're
less interested in understanding his problems than getting film of him
and his six-shooter.
These border residents are routinely snickered at and called racist vigilantes.
But most are decent folks caught up in the daily invasion of illegals
who tramp across their land. Ranchers in hard-hit areas spend the first
hours of every day repairing damage done the night before. They find fences
knocked down and water spigots left on, draining thousands of precious
gallons. And then there's the trash: pill bottles, syringes, used needles,
and pile after pile of human feces.
Sometimes illegals hammer on residents' windows in the middle of the night,
demanding to use the phone. Some even walk right into the ranch house
and refuse to leave until the rancher pulls a gun and forces the issue.
One rancher told me about illegals who rustled one of her newborn calves.
The intruders beat the 12-hour-old animal to death with a fence post,
then barbecued it on the spot.
How bad is it? In the Tucson Sector alone in January 2005, the Border
Patrol arrested 35,704 people, seized 34,864 pounds of marijuana, and
impounded 557 smuggling vehicles. In one month. High-speed chases and
accidents on our back-roads are now common. Residents know to stay off
certain roads at night because the smugglers--of people and drugs--own
them, and if you're not careful they'll come around a bend at 100 mph
and run you into a ditch or worse.
In some hilltop spots near Douglas, you can unfold a lawn chair, crack
open a Schlitz and watch the invasion happen. As dusk falls, they come,
hundreds of headlights from Mexican cabs streaming north, each filled
to the windows with soon-to-be illegals. Are they good folks? Are they
carrying biological agents? We have no idea. They could be the worst terrorists
and thugs. If that sounds alarmist, consider that some ranchers have found
Muslim prayer rugs and Arabic dictionaries on their property. And the
feds confirm that the ultraviolent Mara Salvatrucha street gang is using
Arizona as a gateway into this country.
But you haven't heard much about these problems nationally, because the
media soft-pedal them. Why? It's politically incorrect. We've built a
new third rail in American life. Leave the harmless illegals alone and
go after their victims instead.
I've interviewed a fellow named Bud Strom, a retired Marine and a pretty
fair cowboy poet who has a ranch south of Sierra Vista. He tells about
a reporter for the New York Times coming out to his place and doing a
story on what it's like to live on the border. "The story made it
sound like I was out there helping them, giving them water and such,"
says Bud laughing. In fact, when he sees a group, he wheels his horse
and gets out of there fast, then calls the Border Patrol.
Bud knows what he's dealing with. He has had a truck stolen, found bales
of drugs on his land, and routinely has illegals approach him demanding
beer. It used to be that one or two would ask a local resident for water
and a sandwich, and, once fed, be on their way with a polite "Gracias,
Señorita." The new breed now comes in groups of 50. They demand
to be driven to their pickup spot, and if you refuse they flip you off.
Sometimes they poison barking ranch dogs or cut their throats to quiet
them. How long do you suppose such outrages would go on in Fairfield,
Conn.? Or Greenwich? It'd be a day and a half before some kumbaya-liberal
flipped sides and founded the Merritt Parkway Minutemen. Or the BlackBerry
The best part of this story is that while the elite media's agenda on
the Minutemen played well on the coasts, Arizonans weren't buying it.
A poll found that 57% of the state's residents supported the border-watch
project, which sent the editorial page of Tucson's Arizona Daily Star
into a stammering fit, calling the number alarming. Of course, this is
a paper so politically correct it can't even bring itself to call illegals
illegals. Its writers refer to them as migrants or, my favorite, border
crossers. But as the Minutemen plan to expand operations to five more
states--and a new citizen group, the Yuma Patriots, begins patrolling--that
57% heartens me. It looks to me like the rednecks won.
Mr. Banks is a writer in Tucson.